The novel Pride and Prejudice.

Chapter 22: Chapter 21: Elizabeth’s Rebuttal



Elizabeth Bennet's heart pounded as she strode across the manicured grounds of Rosings Park, her footsteps quick and her cheeks flushed with indignation. The letter in her hand trembled slightly, not from weakness but from the sheer force of the emotions coursing through her. Each carefully inked word had left its mark on her, igniting a tempest that demanded resolution. She turned a corner in the hedgerow and spotted him—Mr. Darcy, his figure tall and commanding against the backdrop of a soft morning haze.

He stood near the edge of the fountain, his posture as rigid as the marble statue at its center. He was staring into the water as if it held answers to questions he dared not voice aloud. Elizabeth slowed her approach, her fury momentarily tempered by his pensive stance. Yet as he turned and his piercing gaze met hers, the flame reignited.

"Miss Bennet," Darcy greeted her, his voice steady but laced with something that might have been trepidation.

"Mr. Darcy," she replied curtly, stopping just short of him. Her tone carried an edge sharp enough to cut through the crisp morning air.

"Have you received my letter?" he asked, his expression inscrutable.

Elizabeth lifted the folded paper, her fingers tightening around it. "I have, indeed. And it is precisely the contents of this letter that compel me to speak with you."

Darcy's brow furrowed, but he gestured toward a shaded bench nearby. "Shall we sit?"

"No," Elizabeth said quickly, her voice firm. "This conversation will not require comfort, nor does it deserve the pretense of civility. You have done me the courtesy of honesty, and I shall return the favor with mine."

Darcy's lips pressed into a thin line, but he nodded. "Very well."

Elizabeth drew in a breath, steadying herself. "I hardly know where to begin, Mr. Darcy. Perhaps with your confessed interference in my sister's happiness. Do you deny that you have separated Jane and Mr. Bingley, though you knew of her affection for him?"

Darcy's expression darkened, and he crossed his arms. "I do not deny it. My actions were deliberate, and I believe they were justified."

"Justified?" Elizabeth's voice rose, incredulity threading through her words. "You deliberately ruined the prospect of happiness for a woman of gentle heart and impeccable character. And you have the audacity to justify such cruelty?"

"I did not act out of cruelty, Miss Bennet," Darcy replied, his tone measured but unwavering. "I acted out of concern for my friend. It was clear to me that your sister's feelings, while kind, did not match the fervor of Bingley's. He would have bound himself to a union unbalanced in affection, to his detriment."

Elizabeth stared at him, her chest rising and falling with the force of her breath. "You presumed to judge her feelings, then? As if you are privy to the depths of her heart? How dare you, Mr. Darcy?"

Darcy shifted, his gaze faltering for the briefest moment before returning to hers. "I observed what was apparent, Miss Bennet. And if I misjudged, then I take full responsibility. But I acted with the best of intentions."

"Your best intentions, sir, have brought nothing but heartbreak," Elizabeth snapped. "Jane is the truest and most tender of souls. She has suffered deeply, though she would never wear her pain for all to see. And you—" she took a step closer, her voice trembling with emotion, "you, with your arrogance and pride, dared to play God with her life."

Darcy's jaw tightened, but he said nothing. The silence stretched between them, taut and heavy.

Elizabeth exhaled sharply, her anger spilling over into the next accusation that had burned in her chest since reading his letter. "And then there is Mr. Wickham."

Darcy's expression shifted instantly, his features hardening as if struck by a sudden chill. "What of him?"

"You need not feign ignorance," Elizabeth retorted. "You have slandered him in your letter, accusing him of heinous deeds without offering a shred of proof. Have you no shame, Mr. Darcy? To vilify a man who has been nothing but amiable and kind?"

Darcy's face was as unreadable as a stone mask, but his voice cut through the air like steel. "Mr. Wickham is neither amiable nor kind. He is a liar, a scoundrel, and a man without honor. Everything I wrote of him is true."

"And yet you expect me to take your word as gospel?" Elizabeth challenged, her eyes blazing. "You, whose actions have already caused such harm? What am I to believe, Mr. Darcy? Your word against his?"

Darcy stepped closer, his height casting a shadow over her. "Believe what you will, Miss Bennet. But know this: Mr. Wickham attempted to elope with my sister for her fortune. Had I not intervened, Georgiana would have been ruined. Is this the man you defend?"

The weight of his words struck Elizabeth like a blow. She faltered, the fire in her eyes dimming as doubt crept into her mind. Could it be true? Could Wickham, with his easy charm and warm smiles, have harbored such deceitful intentions?

Darcy's gaze softened as he noticed her hesitation. "I did not share this lightly, Miss Bennet. Georgiana is dear to me, and the pain of her near-ruin is not something I would willingly relive. But I could not let you remain deceived by Wickham's lies."

Elizabeth looked down at the letter in her hand, its folded edges now crumpled from the force of her grip. The truth, or what she believed to be the truth, now seemed far more elusive than it had moments ago. She glanced back up at Darcy, her voice quieter but no less firm. "If what you say is true, then I have indeed been deceived. But it does not absolve you of the pain you have caused my sister. Nor does it erase the arrogance with which you have treated me and my family."

Darcy inclined his head, his expression somber. "I do not expect your forgiveness, Miss Bennet. Nor do I seek it. My actions were imperfect, but my intentions were sincere. That is all I can offer."

Elizabeth studied him for a long moment, her emotions a storm she could barely contain. The man before her was not the villain she had once believed him to be, but neither was he wholly innocent. His pride and prejudice had caused harm, just as hers had blinded her to the complexity of his character.

"I cannot excuse you, Mr. Darcy," she said at last, her voice trembling but steady. "But I thank you for your honesty."

Darcy's shoulders relaxed slightly, though his expression remained grave. "And I thank you for hearing me, Miss Bennet. I wish you well."

He turned and began to walk away, his tall figure retreating into the mist that hung over the grounds. Elizabeth watched him go, her heart a tumult of conflicting emotions. She felt anger, sorrow, and something she could not yet name—something that left her standing there long after he had disappeared from view.

As the sun began to break through the haze, Elizabeth folded the letter and tucked it away. The day ahead would bring no easy answers, but for now, she resolved to carry the weight of her new understanding, however heavy it might be.


Tip: You can use left, right, A and D keyboard keys to browse between chapters.