1960: My Uncle is the Director of the FBI

Hayes finally chose to admit that he killed Hattie Earl.

The confession came near midnight, fluorescent lights humming overhead in the cramped interrogation room.

Since it was late, Hayes was temporarily held at the Fifth Precinct. Tomorrow, Theodore and Bernie would return to tie up the loose ends and close the case.

The Fifth Precinct Deputy Police Commissioner watched the two federal agents disappear into the December night, then immediately summoned Detective Ross to his office.

The blinds were drawn against the snow-dusted windows, and the air was thick with the smell of cigarette smoke.

Although Theodore and Bernie had been investigating intermittently for some time last week, the speed on a cold case was still astonishing.

The Deputy Police Commissioner had seen plenty of Bureau hotshots come through his precinct; most left empty-handed after weeks of fruitless effort.

He listened intently as Detective Ross delivered his report, instructed him to prepare the paperwork for submission, then made his way down to the detention block to see Hayes for himself.

Hayes sat slumped on the metal cot, still reeling from Theodore and Bernie's methodical dismantling of his defenses. The fight had gone out of him completely.

He answered whatever the Deputy Police Commissioner asked with the hollow monotone of a man who'd given up all pretense.

Leaving the detention room, the Deputy Police Commissioner felt disoriented, almost dizzy.

He'd expected this to be another FBI fishing expedition, a bureaucratic exercise that would drag on for months before quietly disappearing into some Washington file cabinet.

Instead, not only had the case been cracked with surgical precision, but they'd caught the actual killers.

His thoughts turned inevitably to Detective Coleman, now facing federal charges.

The collusion between Coleman and Hayes wasn't unprecedented; he'd seen similar corruption more times than he cared to count.

The real problem was getting caught red-handed by a federal agent. And not just any agent, but J. Edgar fucking Hoover's nephew.

The Deputy Police Commissioner climbed the stairs to his office and reached for the phone. The Fifth Precinct Chief needed to hear about this immediately.

Pennsylvania Avenue stretched before them like a frozen river, brake lights bleeding red through the falling snow.

D.C.'s traffic had deteriorated steadily since the storm began, and the northwestern route from the Capitol moved with the sluggish persistence of molasses.

Theodore used the crawling pace to his advantage, systematically introducing Bernie to the fundamentals of criminal personality profiling and psychological analysis.

The Buick's heater hummed steadily as he laid out concepts that wouldn't become mainstream law enforcement practice for another two decades.

"The key distinction," Theodore explained, adjusting the rearview mirror to catch Bernie's expression, "lies between modus operandi and what we call identifying marks or signature behaviors."

Bernie leaned forward from the passenger seat, notebook balanced on his knee despite the car's gentle swaying.

"Modus operandi encompasses the necessary actions a criminal must take to commit their crime successfully. It's practical, adaptive, focused on ensuring success, minimizing risk, and avoiding capture. As criminals gain experience or encounter new circumstances, their M.O. evolves."

Theodore downshifted as they approached another red light, the engine settling into an idle rumble.

"Identifying marks, however, serve no practical purpose in committing the crime. They're compulsive behaviors driven by deep psychological needs, fantasies, emotional requirements, or attempts at psychological compensation."

"These behaviors remain remarkably consistent across different crimes because they reflect the criminal's core psychological makeup."

He watched Bernie scribble notes, then continued.

"Think of it this way: M.O. addresses the question 'How does he commit the crime?' Signature behavior answers 'Why does he commit it that particular way?'"

The light changed, and they crawled forward another block. Snow continued to dust the windshield despite the steady rhythm of the wipers.

"Most law enforcement agencies focus exclusively on modus operandi," Theodore said.

"They analyze the practical aspects, tools used, points of entry, and methods of control, hoping to match patterns with known offenders. Criminal profiling takes the opposite approach."

"We study the signature behaviors to understand the psychological profile, then work backwards to identify potential suspects."

Bernie looked up from his notes, confusion creasing his features.

Theodore recognized the expression and shifted to concrete examples. "Let's examine the Earl family murders through this lens."

The familiar weight of the case file seemed to materialize between them, though both men knew its contents by memory.

"Hayes's sexual assault of Hattie Earl served no practical purpose in debt collection. Even if successful, it wouldn't have generated money to satisfy Clarence Earl's outstanding obligations."

"Yet Hayes committed this act anyway, driven by his need to dominate and control, the same psychological compulsion that led him to select vulnerable families as tenants."

Bernie nodded slowly, beginning to see the pattern.

"After Hattie Earl was strangled, both Clarence and Mabel Earl fought back. At that point, killing them became operationally necessary, the only way to prevent exposure of Coleman and Hayes's crimes. However, Coleman's actions went far beyond operational requirements."

Theodore's voice took on the clinical tone he'd once used in lecture halls that wouldn't exist for decades.

"Coleman fired multiple rounds into Clarence Earl when one would have sufficed. More tellingly, he adopted a specific posture when executing Mabel Earl, standing over her, weapon pointed downward."

"These behaviors served no practical purpose. Instead, Coleman was reinforcing his sense of racial superiority through the execution stance and releasing his anger about losing control of the situation through excessive force."

They'd reached Dupont Circle, where the traffic opened up slightly. Bernie used the smoother ride to catch up on his notes.

"Using pure profiling methodology," Theodore continued.

"We should have analyzed the crime scene to identify signature behaviors, then filtered potential suspects based on psychological profile rather than opportunity or means."

He paused, waiting for Bernie to finish writing.

"Based on the signature evidence, we would have been looking for two offenders. The dominant partner: armed, possessing strong racial prejudices and control issues, directing the overall criminal activity."

"The subordinate partner: resentful of the leader's dominance but too intimidated to challenge him directly, seeking to assert control over even weaker victims, in this case, through the assault of Hattie Earl."

Bernie's pen had stopped moving. His expression suggested the pieces were clicking into place.

"This profile matches exactly what we discovered in Felton," he said quietly.

"Precisely. However—" Theodore's tone shifted, becoming more instructional, "—ideal conditions rarely exist in the field. In this case, Detective Coleman's deliberate contamination of evidence severely limited our ability to extract behavioral signatures from the crime scene."

They'd entered the residential neighborhoods now, tree-lined streets where snow accumulated on dormant lawns and porch railings.

"When physical evidence is compromised, we must rely on inferential analysis combined with statistical probabilities. The subordinate's willingness to display his resentment even while committing crimes with his domineering partner suggests a pattern of similar behavior in other contexts."

Theodore could see Bernie struggling to follow the logical progression.

"Hayes's tenant selection process reflects this dynamic perfectly. His preference for vulnerable families gave him the same sense of control over people weaker than himself that Coleman exercised over him."

"One word from Hayes could destroy a tenant family's stability, just as one word from Coleman could destroy Hayes. It's not merely a pursuit of power, but an unconscious replication of the power structure that dominates his own life."

Theodore glanced over and caught Bernie mid-yawn. He stopped talking and studied his partner's face in the dashboard lights.

"You don't understand, do you?"

Bernie offered a sheepish smile. "The first part made sense. The identifying marks and M.O.. I can see how that applies to the cases we worked in Felton. But after that..." He shrugged helplessly.

Theodore felt no disappointment. He'd been attempting to condense decades of research by hundreds of criminologists into a single hour-long presentation. Bernie's confusion was entirely reasonable.

He abandoned the theoretical framework and let his mind drift to practical considerations.

Originally, he'd planned to form an investigative team and develop techniques through field experience, building theoretical foundations from successful casework.

But Bernie's reaction suggested that formal research and training protocols would be equally crucial.

Theodore reached for the notebook he kept tucked beside the driver's seat and jotted down several reminders while stopped at another red light.

Bernie watched him write, thinking: 'It really isn't just a learnable skill, is it?'

The concepts Theodore had explained initially, identifying marks versus modus operandi, could be verified against their Felton cases with startling clarity.

But the advanced inferential techniques Theodore described seemed to require an almost supernatural intuition about human behavior.

Bernie found himself wondering if Theodore fully grasped his own unique abilities.

The man kept insisting these methods could be taught to any competent investigator, but Bernie had serious doubts.

What else could explain such insights except some form of extraordinary talent?

The next morning, they found themselves in the imposing corridors of the Department of Justice Building, reporting to Supervisor Rosen's office with the case resolution.

Rosen had arrived early, having received preliminary details from the Fifth Precinct Chief the previous evening.

His particular interest in Theodore's rapid case-solving methodology stemmed from pressing departmental concerns.

Year-end statistics were due soon, and the Investigation Department's clearance rates told a troubling story.

Supervisor Rosen had spent considerable time analyzing the numbers.

Despite the continuous expansion of personnel, improved agent training, and increasingly sophisticated laboratory capabilities, clearance rates continued to decline steadily across all crime categories.

Criminals seemed to be getting smarter faster than law enforcement could keep up with.

Bernie had prepared a comprehensive briefing the previous night, drawing on Theodore's systematic explanations during their drive.

The structured presentation covered each phase of their investigation, from initial crime scene analysis through psychological profiling to suspect interrogation.

With Theodore's theoretical framework fresh in his mind, Bernie felt that he'd created a clear and logical account of their methodology.

Supervisor Rosen listened attentively but found himself increasingly mystified. The investigation seemed more like elaborate fortune-telling than detective work.

How could anyone predict a suspect's behavior so precisely based on such limited information?

Still, results spoke louder than theory. Two cold cases were solved in record time, with confessions and federal charges filed.

"Close this case as quickly as possible," Supervisor Rosen instructed. "I want the final report on my desk within the week."

The Fifth Precinct's Deputy Police Commissioner personally oversaw the case closure proceedings, ensuring unprecedented cooperation with the federal agents.

Paperwork that usually took weeks was processed in days.

Bernie tackled the closing report himself, politely declining Theodore's offer of assistance. The FBI's documentation requirements differed significantly from those of the Felton Police Department.

Everything here followed standardized protocols outlined in thick procedural manuals, including formats, writing procedures, and approval processes, all of which were precisely specified.

The closing report format demanded case numbers, comprehensive summaries, arrest details, evidence inventories, and justification for federal jurisdiction.

The case summary section required chronological timelines, key evidence analysis, and a detailed explanation of suspect identification methods.

Therein lay Bernie's challenge. Their primary evidence consisted of Hayes's confession. Their suspect identification process relied entirely on what outsiders would perceive as educated guesswork.

Fortunately, Bernie's habit of detailed note-taking provided enough material to reconstruct their investigative reasoning.

Still, he found himself struggling to translate Theodore's intuitive leaps into acceptable Bureau language.

Eventually, Bernie retrieved Ronald's closing report from the post office robbery case and borrowed liberally from its structure and phrasing.

"If your investigation team actually gets approved," Bernie told Theodore upon completing the report, "you absolutely must hire a good writer. I have a feeling these brain-wracking documentation sessions will only multiply."

Theodore considered this suggestion seriously, opened his notebook, and made a note of it. He asked Bernie if he had any other recommendations for team composition.

Bernie waved him off and delivered the report to Supervisor Rosen's office.

Rosen examined the closing report immediately, noting extensive analytical sections that reminded him strongly of Ronald's recent work. He compared both documents, checked his statistical summaries, and made a decision.

With the New Year approaching and Jack Kennedy's inauguration looming, J. Edgar Hoover had been particularly busy.

The incoming Attorney General, Robert Kennedy, had made his intentions unmistakably clear through intermediaries. He planned comprehensive FBI reforms and an aggressive pursuit of organized crime.

Both initiatives struck directly at Hoover's most sensitive areas. For years, the Director had steadfastly denied the existence of organized crime in America.

Even after the notorious 1957 Appalachin Meeting, when New York State Police stumbled upon dozens of Mafia bosses gathered at Joseph Barbara's estate, the Bureau had maintained its passive stance toward organized crime investigation.

Reform meant dismantling Hoover's carefully constructed power structure. The organized crime focus meant admitting to decades of willful negligence. Either initiative could fatally damage Hoover's position.

The Director was discussing countermeasures with Associate Director Clyde Tolson when Supervisor Rosen knocked and entered the inner sanctum.

Rosen had worked under Hoover long enough to read the room's atmosphere. Both men wore expressions of barely controlled irritation.

Rather than risk small talk or retreat, Rosen plunged directly into his presentation.

He placed both closing reports on Hoover's desk, briefly outlined the cases, and emphasized Theodore's central role in both rapid resolutions.

Then he made his formal request: immediate transfer of Theodore to the Investigation Department, with authorization to establish an independent investigation team reporting directly to Rosen himself.

Rosen's praise for Theodore was unqualified. He admitted the Investigation Department's recent performance shortcomings and requested full support for this new initiative.

Hoover's furrowed brow gradually smoothed as he absorbed Rosen's words. The corner of his mouth twitched upward before he remembered Tolson's presence and suppressed the expression.

"Alex," Hoover said dismissively, "your evaluation lacks objectivity. Theodore is young, inexperienced, and hardly qualified for independent command."

Rosen glanced desperately toward Tolson, struggling to maintain his composure.

Hoover coughed meaningfully and also looked at Tolson, leaving the reports on his desk and dismissing Rosen without further comment.

After Rosen departed, Hoover drummed his fingers against the desktop and snorted softly.

"Let him know Alex thinks so highly of him, and he'll develop an ego problem."

Tolson's eyes caught Hoover's barely suppressed smile. "What do you intend to do?"

Hoover flipped through the reports without hesitation. "Alex can't control him properly."

"This investigation team will operate under the Investigation Department but report directly to you."

Tolson expected this decision and nodded in agreement. He used the opportunity to present several files from the January trainee selection process.

Hoover carefully reviewed each candidate profile while continuing his discussion of the Kennedy brothers' threat. Suppressing presidents was familiar territory for both men.

They quickly developed a strategy to apply pressure on Congress against the incoming administration.

Hoover checked his watch; it was already past noon. He handed the selected trainee files to Tolson, retrieved his coat from the closet, and began discussing Christmas holiday arrangements.

For once, Hoover seemed genuinely enthusiastic. This represented one of the few periods each year when he could truly relax. He planned to vacation in Miami and intended to bring Theodore along.

Tolson reminded him tactfully that Theodore might have his own holiday plans.

Hoover fell silent, suddenly realizing he'd never considered that possibility.

[End of Chapter]

__________________

Check out more than 65+ chapters right now! 🔥

👉 patreon.com/cw/Mr_UmU

https://www.patreon.com/Mr_UmU